Staples Sustainable Earth Notebook

Photo of Staples Sustainable Earth cover

Front cover

I stopped into Staples the other day to get a Black n’ Red wirebound notebook. They didn’t have any in the size I wanted so I looked for alternatives. The Staples Sustainable Earth 9.5″ X 6′ wirebound notebook caught my eye at less than $5.

The paper is sugar-cane based which is where the sustainable comes from. The paper seemed rather flimsy but I decided to give it a try. The pages are perforated and at 100 sheets I figured I’d find some use for it.

The wirebound notebook has a thick cardboard cover and two pockets inside the notebook. The spiral binding is thick wire so the notebook seemed like it would hold up fairly well being carried in my bag. After I got home I did an internet search and it seems the paper quality varies widely. My notebook was made in Egypt. There’s a whole line of sustainable earth notebooks and I have no idea if the variation is between styles or within the same style, so your mileage may vary.

The paper is thin so there is show through, even with my thin nibs. Since wirebound notebooks are uncomfortable half the time (if bound on the side) I don’t often write on the back so this isn’t a huge issue for me. But when I did write on both sides the show-through didn’t bother me.

There wasn’t any bleed-through to speak of. One small dot did soak through when I repeatedly wrote over the same area. A swab did bleed-through just a little. Thick, wet nibs may not like this paper.

The inks I used behaved surprisingly well with this paper. It’s fountain pen friendly in my opinion. It’s not Rhodia, but it’s not priced at Rhodia levels.

The paper holds up surprisingly well even though it seems so flimsy. I use the notebook at work and flip back and forth through pages all the time and the paper has not torn or come loose from the wire. It wrinkles a bit, but doesn’t tear. The micro-perforations work well.

I’m not sure I buy into the eco-friendly marketing. I bought the pad because of the low price and trees can be replanted. According to the marketing blurb inside the notebook the paper is

… made from 80% sugarcane plant fiber waste. After sugarcane is processed and crushed to make sugar, the waste is converted into paper.

Using more parts of anything to reduce waste is good, so apparently it’s not just because less trees are used.

I find the notebook suitable for my use – work notes and checklists. The price is right at $5 but I’d be sure to check the paper before each purchase. Just like the Black & Red notebook I went to Staples to get.

Gallery

 

About these ads

Review: Doane Paper

I think I first learned of Doane Paper from Brad Dowdy’s Flickr stream where Doane Paper was almost always the backdrop in the pen photos and what he used to write his pen reviews. But since I’m not a fan of grid paper it wasn’t until last year that I gave it a try. I’ve been using it since. The two writing tablet sizes along with the large Flap Jotter are standard for me. The written review is in the photo gallery along with writing samples. The large writing pad is the same paper as the smaller one, so I only did samples on the small pad.

The written review doesn’t make it clear that there are two “Flap Jotter” sizes, I use the larger of the two. The smaller pad does use the same paper.

I don’t mention drying times in the hand written review, but they are generally pretty good. Inks dry faster than on Rhodia but slower than on cheaper paper that absorbs the ink. I don’t have to be especially careful when writing (I’m a righty) but I tend to use thin nibs and quicker drying ink as a general rule. I do occasionally get careless and notice a smudge.

On to the written review and writing samples. Click any thumbnail to open the gallery.

Rhodia DotPad Quick Look

The Rhodia DotPad has become a mainstay on my desk. I use it for quick notes, doodles, lists and more. At first I thought the 80g paper was a little too slick and I put the pad aside. Finally I gave in to the near universal consensus that it was great fountain pen paper and pulled it out again. I’m glad I did because after using it awhile I came to like it. The paper is a little thin for my taste and I don’t think it would travel well in my bag so it stays inside.

The dots are just on one side of the paper although they do show through. This isn’t really a problem as I typically only use one side. There is also some show through with darker ink, but again not an issue for me. I’ve never experienced any bleed-through although I typically use extra-fine and fine nibs.

A review written on the Rhodia Dotpad, click the image to see it full size.

Picture of the Rhodia DotPad hand written review

Rhodia No. 16 DotPad hand written review